As you may or may not know, I’m in the throes of writing a book for Moody Publishers – part of which involves me listening to only Christian music for a whole year. As such, part of that commitment includes only going to Christian concerts.
I went to one last night, with my Christian Music Sherpa, Zach, called Winter Blast (which sounds to me like a chewing gum brand…ex: Try Dentyne’s WINTER BLAST! Not to be confused with Winter Jam, which is another Christian music festival)…but is actually a multi-act show-slash-shill for World Vision. I went to Winter Blast largely because it was only ten dollars, I had heard of one of the bands (Building 429) and it was at a local megachurch near my house (Mt. Hope Church) that I was really curious to see the inside of (which ended up looking, surprisingly, a lot like a church).
Editor’s Note: I sound like a jerk in this post. The book will be tamer.
Bits of Dialogue, Exchanged with Zach, Before the Show Started:
- Upon seeing a banner with pictures of the Mt. Hope pastors, Zach pointed to one and said “Have you read his book called ‘Ten Ways to Survive if You Miss the Rapture’?” I hadn’t. He went on to explain that one of the ten ways to survive involved stocking up on a lot of batteries and listening to the radio.
- Me, upon entering the venue and scanning the crowd: “I feel like we’re chaperones at a youth group lock-in.”
It would get way, way weirder. The show started with a band called Echoing Angels, who actually ended up being the most talented group on the entire bill. To picture Echoing Angels, imagine the five coolest kids in your high school youth group. Now imagine them a few years older, with guitars in their hands. From where we sat, the front man looked a lot like a puffier Luke Wilson – come to think of it, a lot like Luke Wilson looks in the cell phone ads he’s doing now.
Me: “I wonder what Christian college these guys led worship at before they started doing this?”
Zach: “I wonder what mid-sized megachurch these guys are the house band for, currently?”
Echoing Angels, like I said, was the highlight of the night. They were actually quite talented and played a tight set that was too short. After Echoing Angels, Zach and I took a spin through the concourse/narthex past the merch tables, where we realized that kind of urbany/willowy font that Relevant Magazine made cool six years ago had been utilized on absolutely every piece of merchandise (shirts, CD’s, hats, wristbands, keychains, glossy band photos, etc.) available for purchase.
One Immutable Law of the Universe: Lead guitar players are always tall/willowy/attractive, while bass players are always squatty, with a low center of gravity – like the kid who played offensive guard on your high school’s football team. Why is this?
We both felt very creepy/old when we both walked by Britt Nicole’s merch table and both noticed a very unintentionally(?) seductivey glossy photo of her in a sun dress on a bike. We both thought of Debbie Gibson, on whom we both had crushes as middle schoolers. We both felt weird. Herein lies the dilemma with young, Christian pop divas vis a vis unintentionally(?) selling their sexuality. More on that later.
Between sets a guy who looked like Carson Daly (note: everybody who spoke/sang onstage looked like Carson Daly…if looking like Carson Daly means wearing skinny jeans, some kind of leather jacket, and some kind of overly-contrived disheveled hairdo)…came up on stage and let us know that for $30, we would receive a Building 429 poster, a CD, a t-shirt, and “the opportunity to come backstage and pray with the band.” I seriously considered doing this, for research purposes but then cooler heads prevailed.
After offering the opportunity to pay-to-pray, Carson tried to give away some free Building 429 CD’s to audience members. He tried to engage them by asking if anyone knew the name of Building 429’s new hit single. A couple of kids raised their hands but failed to come up with the name. At which point, Carson exclaimed “You’re not devoted,” and left the stage. Seriously, this happened. At which point I turned to Zach and said “That was worth the ten dollars.”
Next was a set by a band called Mike’s Chair. Here’s what I remember about Mike’s Chair: Two of the four members of the band wore yellow scarves over their sweaters. That was enough to make me want to leave the room before they even started playing. (disclaimer: I’m sure they’re great guys and good musicians). One and a half songs into their set I asked Zach if he wanted to go back out into the hallway. He did. In the hallway we found a larger-than-life-sized banner of Mike’s Chair in all of their affluent/suburban/sexy/Christian glory.
Zach: “Mike’s Chair looks like the kind of band that scheduled a photo shoot on the first day they form as a band.”
Me: “Mike’s Chair = Dad’s Money.”
The highlight of the Mike’s Chair set, according to Zach, was that they played a DC Talk song from the mid 1990’s, which we could hear from the plush leather divans we were sitting in, in the Mt. Hope narthex. In those divans, we had a long conversation about the type of hairdo rocked by Mike, the Mike’s Chair frontman (also rocked by many of the other guys onstage throughout the night). It’s a sort of moppy, blonde look not unlike, we decided, the kid on the Dutch Boy paint can, or He-Man from the He-Man cartoons in the 1980’s.
We figured we would have a few minutes between Mike’s Chair and Britt Nicole, but she started playing almost immediately so we went back in. She was wearing an 80’s throwback outfit featuring a black t-shirt, a sort of Madonna material-girl esque puffy black skirt, and leggings. She jumped around onstage a lot and appeared to have a lot of energy. At one point she asked the members of the audience to put their hands in the air, which I did, because for a minute I felt like it was Debbie Gibson asking me to do it. (note: Being reformed, I’ve never put my hands in the air for any reason, up to this point).
Britt Nicole was actually much more interesting between songs. After her first song she told the story of how she got “discovered” by Building 429 and ended up on tour with them. “I was standing in line at a concert to get my CD signed, just like you guys do,” she said (implication: I used to be regular, just like you). “I gave them my demo and figured they never listened to it…but they did and now I’m on stage with them! That’s what God wants to do for you!”
Cue: squeals from the audience.
Other things said by Britt Nicole: “Let me see your spirit fingers!” Zach and I, in the spirit of participation, showed her our spirit fingers (see also: things I never thought I’d do).
That (the fact that God can/wants to make all of your dreams come true) was a common theme throughout the night. A sort of prosperity-follow-your-dreams message.
We make it three songs into Britt Nicole’s set before once again retiring to the divans in the hall, where we realized it had been 20 years since Nirvana’s “Smells Like Teen Spirit” was released. Nothing like a nubile Christian girl in a Debbie Gibson outfit to make you realize how old you are.
It occurred to us that for a rock show to really be a rock show, there had to be some element of danger involved. Even if it isn’t real danger…there has to be something about the music, or the environment, that puts the viewer on edge a little bit. I felt this way at the Metallica show…the Rolling Stones show…even Stryper to a certain degree. Zach then told the story of getting mugged at a Michael W. Smith/Amy Grant concert at the Palace of Auburn Hills when he was ten years old. “A fat guy pushed me up behind a stairwell and asked me if I had any money,” he recalled. “I said yes and he took it all. I cried all the way home.” That, friends, is danger.
The weirdest part of the night would happen after the Britt Nicole set and before Building 429.
Jason Roy, the front guy for Building 429, took the stage immediately after Britt Nicole. Growing up evangelical taught me one thing: If there’s a tinkling piano in the background, there’s going to be some sort of heartstring-pulling talk, followed immediately by an appeal for money and/or an appeal to come up front and get saved. Roy began by telling the audience about a trip he took to “Central America.” Behind him, on a giant screen, flashed giant photos of impoverished children – the kind you always see photographed standing around emergent guys on emergent guys’ blogs.
We figured the talk would be short…and have no problem with World Vision raising money at a World Vision sponsored event (note: I like World Vision and think they do good work…that doesn’t make what follows any less weird-feeling…but I want to acknowledge now that it may be my problem). They have to make the money back somehow. But the talk went on. And on.
Roy spoke about driving past shanties, and asking the cabbie, “What do they store in there?” To which the cabbie replied, “People live in there, Jason.” And then, finally, came the appeal to sponsor children, except that Roy sort of made it clear that the band wouldn’t start playing until the packets for the ten children he was holding in his hand were sponsored. People were told to raise their hands to accept a child.
“Your gift will help these kids go to schools with computers, so that they can move to the city and have a better life,” he said. This was a recurring theme throughout – computers, and the city, equaling a better life. Piano keys still tinkling in the background. The poor pianist had to play for about 45 minutes straight. It occurred to me that after spending most of my adult life in thinky Reformed-ish churches, it had been a long time (college?) since I had experienced one of these super-emotional appeals. We also realized that to be a Christian rock star/band today means linking up with one of these fundraising/help the children/social justice organizations. To be a Christian rock band without a social conscience is to be the worst kind of heel. Though I feel like a heel for writing what I’ve written (and am about to write).
Me: “I feel weird. Let’s go to the hallway.”
Zach: “This is like sitting through the time share talk, so that you can stay in the condo for free.”
Me: “I’ve spent tens of thousands of dollars adopting children in Ukraine…why do I feel like a jerk for not spending $35 on one of these children?”
Zach: “That means it (the appeal) is working. Also, your kids are white. I feel like sponsoring the last five children just so we can hear the band.”
Finally, it was over and there was yet another fifteen minute break before the Building 429 set. Back out in the narthex/concourse we saw Britt Nicole signing autographs for lots of 9-15 year old girls. Near her table was a group of giddy, emo-looking college guys deep into the process of not having the courage to ask for Britt Nicole’s number. The Mike’s Chair guys were standing in front of the giant photo of themselves. We were losing steam, rapidly, for Winter Blast. I’d never wanted to leave a place more in my life, yet I couldn’t really identify why. We decided to lean against the back wall of the auditorium, where we could see the stage but be close to one of the doors to make an early exit, if necessary (hint: necessary).
We were approached by a matronly woman in a shirt that said “usher.”
“Do you guys see what you’re doing to the blinds,” she asked. I didn’t see what we were doing to the blinds (note: there were these weird windows with vertical venetian blinds behind us, which our backs brushed up against, occasionally). “Maybe you can go sit in a seat or something.” (Translation: Go get your cynical, non-child-sponsoring expletives into a seat. Pronto.)